Whose Songs Were These?: The Black repertoire inside the Western swing songbook
— BY RON THOMPSON, November 1, 2026Western swing took shape in Texas and Oklahoma during the 1930s, drawing country fiddle music into the orbit of blues, jazz, ragtime, Tin Pan Alley song, polkas, and waltzes already circulating across the Southwest. It also developed within the legal and social order of Jim Crow, the system of laws, customs, and institutions that enforced racial segregation and restricted the rights and daily movement of Black Americans across the South. By 1930, segregation statutes and local custom across Texas excluded Black residents from cultural events, major hotels, and finer restaurants unless separate accommodations existed. (Texas State Historical Association)
For working musicians, those restrictions governed the logistics of the road. A touring band needed places to play and sleep, reliable transportation, and contacts in each town. Black travelers depended on Black-owned businesses that would house and feed them, and Black musicians established their own unions in cities where the existing locals barred them from membership. (Texas State Historical Association)
Working under Jim Crow
The Jim Hotel in Fort Worth illustrates how that arrangement functioned. Black businessman William Madison “Gooseneck Bill” McDonald built the hotel in the late 1920s, and brothers Levi and Oscar Cooper purchased it in 1934. Downstairs, the College Inn became a central jazz and blues room with T-Bone Walker leading the house band. Louis Armstrong, Count Basie, Ella Fitzgerald, Billie Holiday, Earl Hines, and Art Tatum all played or passed through. The hotel’s registered guests were Black, yet white listeners regularly arrived after midnight to hear the bands and occasionally stayed for early-morning jam sessions. (Texas State Historical Association)
White audiences could walk into the Jim to hear Black performers, while Black travelers could not assume a white hotel or restaurant in town would admit them. Musicians’ unions operated on the same divided footing. Fort Worth’s white American Federation of Musicians Local 72 was chartered in 1898; Black musicians organized separately under Local 392 in 1944. Dallas split white Local 147 from Black Local 168. Neither city merged its locals until 1965, with Fort Worth’s integration taking effect on January 1 and Dallas following later that year. (Musicians DFW)
Alphonso Trent at the Adolphus
Bandleader Alphonso Trent’s tenure in Dallas shows how a Black orchestra could reach a prominent white audience without escaping the racial order surrounding the engagement. Trent led one of the foremost regional jazz orchestras of the 1920s. After entering the Texas market, his ensemble became the first African American band to hold a weekly residency at Dallas’s Adolphus Hotel, with performances broadcast over WFAA. (Texas State Historical Association)
The Handbook of Texas records that Trent’s orchestra received threats from the Ku Klux Klan for playing to the hotel’s white clientele. Headlining one of Dallas’ premier ballrooms and reaching listeners across the region by radio did not alter the rules awaiting those musicians once they stepped off the bandstand. (Texas State Historical Association)
Bob Wills and Ernie Fields
A comparable proximity shaped the careers of Bob Wills and Ernie Fields in Tulsa. By 1935, Wills and his Texas Playboys had made Cain’s Ballroom their base for regular dances and KVOO broadcasts. Fields led what the Oklahoma Historical Society classifies as a “territory band,” working a regional circuit linking Kansas City, Tulsa, Oklahoma City, and Dallas, and building one of the most popular Black orchestras in the Southwest. (Oklahoma Historical Society)
Jim Crow confined most of Tulsa’s Black nightlife to the Greenwood District, where the Rhythm Club, Casa Dell, Rialto Theater, and the Hole anchored local music. Still, professional relationships crossed the line. In an oral-history interview preserved by the Oklahoma Historical Society, Fields’ daughter, Carmen Fields, recalled Wills advising her father on fee structures, recommending venues, and referring promoters when the Texas Playboys were booked. She also credited Wills with helping the Ernie Fields Orchestra become the first Black act to perform at Cain’s Ballroom, a milestone corroborated in Oklahoma Historical Society records. (Oklahoma Historical Society)
The record business and after hours
Record companies drew cleaner boundaries on paper than existed on the bandstand. During the 1920s, labels divided Southern catalogs into “race records” marketed to Black buyers and “hillbilly” or “old-time” records aimed at rural white buyers. As historian Karl Hagstrom Miller argues in Segregating Sound, those commercial categories imposed racial divisions onto a musical culture in which Black and white players routinely drew from the same pool of blues, ballads, string-band numbers, popular songs, and Broadway material. (Duke University Press)
White Western swing musicians often absorbed that repertoire in person after hours. Light Crust Doughboys banjoist Marvin “Smokey” Montgomery later recalled visiting Black clubs in Dallas’ Deep Ellum and Fort Worth’s Jim Hotel with fellow musicians, noting that guitarist Muryel “Zeke” Campbell developed much of his single-note technique in those rooms. Montgomery’s recollection establishes where Campbell went and what he learned, though the Black guitarists he heard and played alongside remain unnamed in the account. (Fort Worth Magazine)
Bob Wills’s own background contains similar tensions. Growing up in Texas, he learned blues and jazz from Black neighbors and migrant workers, and as a young man he rode roughly fifty miles on horseback to hear Bessie Smith sing. Yet after moving to Fort Worth in 1929, Wills also performed in a blackface minstrel show, a theatrical tradition rooted in racial caricature and derision, as documented by the Smithsonian’s National Museum of African American History and Culture. The archive holds both facts without resolving them: Wills admired Black performers, learned from Black musical traditions, and backed peers such as Ernie Fields, while also taking part in a racist stage convention of his era. (Country Music Hall of Fame and Museum; Oklahoma Historical Society)
The songs
Examining individual compositions replaces broad talk of blues and jazz influence with specific sessions and dates.
When Wills cut his first test session for Brunswick with guitarist Herman Arnspiger in November 1929, the two titles were “Wills Breakdown” and “Gulf Coast Blues.” Black pianist and songwriter Clarence Williams wrote “Gulf Coast Blues,” and Bessie Smith recorded it in 1923 with Williams at the piano. From his first day in a studio, Wills was recording material composed by a Black songwriter and popularized by the foremost Black vocalist of the decade. (Country Music Hall of Fame and Museum; The Library of Congress)
The Mississippi Sheiks leave another clear trail. Central members Walter Vinson and fiddler Lonnie Chatmon performed for both Black and white audiences, and their 1930 recording of “Sitting on Top of the World” became the group’s best-selling record. White country acts, including Milton Brown and Bob Wills, adopted the tune during the 1930s. Wills and the Texas Playboys recorded their version in Dallas on September 24, 1935, five years after the Sheiks’ release. (Country Music Hall of Fame and Museum; UCSB Library)
The Chatmon family reappears in “Corrine Corrina.” Drawing on older floating folk verses, Bo Chatmon, better known as Bo Carter, and Charlie McCoy recorded their influential version in December 1928, a performance the Country Music Hall of Fame includes in its history of Black string-band music. Wills and the Texas Playboys recorded the song in 1940. (Country Music Hall of Fame and Museum)
Beyond the blues
Black Broadway and jazz composers fed Western swing just as directly as rural string bands.
Harlem stride pianist James P. Johnson composed “Old Fashioned Love,” with lyrics by Cecil Mack, for the 1923 Broadway musical Runnin’ Wild. Wills and the Texas Playboys recorded it in Dallas on September 24, 1935, during the same session that produced “Sitting on Top of the World.” One piece originated in a Black Broadway revue and the other with a Mississippi string band; both entered the Texas Playboys’ recorded catalog on the same afternoon. (The Library of Congress; UCSB Library)
The following year, Wills and the band recorded Richard M. Jones’s “Trouble in Mind” for Vocalion alongside Spencer Williams’s “Basin Street Blues,” which Louis Armstrong had recorded in 1928. Restoring those credits turns abstract claims about Western swing’s hybridity into a verifiable list of working writers. (Jazz Standards; The Library of Congress)
“Milk Cow Blues” and “Guitar Rag”
Two instrument-defining Western swing numbers make the lineage especially clear.
On September 10, 1934, Georgia bottleneck guitarist Kokomo Arnold recorded “Milk Cow Blues” for Decca in Chicago. By early 1937, Cliff Bruner’s Texas Wanderers had cut the first Western swing version. Music scholars Jean A. Boyd and Patrick Kelly note that we cannot determine precisely how Bruner encountered the song, whether from Arnold’s record, a live performance, or wider circulation in Texas, but comparing the recordings demonstrates that Bruner followed Arnold’s first arrangement closely while adapting it for a dance band. (Gato Documentation)
Louisville guitarist Sylvester Weaver offers a tighter connection, alongside evidence of how authorship could disappear across racial lines. Weaver recorded “Guitar Rag” in 1923 and again in 1927. Smithsonian Folkways traces the Texas Playboys’ 1936 instrumental hit “Steel Guitar Rag,” featuring Leon McAuliffe on steel guitar, directly to Weaver’s 1923 side. When the Playboys’ record was released, however, McAuliffe was listed as sole composer, and Weaver received neither credit nor royalties. (Folkways Media)
Listening in both directions
Musical exchange did not move in a single direction. The Mississippi Sheiks recorded “Yodeling Fiddling Blues,” a performance the Country Music Hall of Fame identifies as reflecting the influence of their contemporary Jimmie Rodgers. Black and white Southern musicians listened to one another, shared songs, and bought the same records even as the industry sorted their work into separate commercial bins. (Country Music Hall of Fame and Museum)
Jim Crow governed the terms of that circulation. Segregation restricted where Black musicians could sleep, eat, unionize, and perform, requiring them to build parallel institutions while occasionally entering white ballrooms under conditions unusual enough to enter the historical record. Tracing the repertoire back to Clarence Williams, Bessie Smith, Walter Vinson, Lonnie and Bo Chatmon, Charlie McCoy, James P. Johnson, Cecil Mack, Richard M. Jones, Spencer Williams, Kokomo Arnold, and Sylvester Weaver recovers the musicians whose compositions and recordings were already in motion when Western swing bands heard them, played them, and carried them into another corner of American music. (Texas State Historical Association; The Library of Congress)
Selected references
Handbook of Texas: Segregation; Jim Hotel; Alphonso E. Trent
Oklahoma Historical Society: Ernie Fields; Carmen Fields oral-history interview
Country Music Hall of Fame: Bob Wills
Duke University Press: Karl Hagstrom Miller, Segregating Sound
Smithsonian Folkways: notes on Sylvester Weaver and “Steel Guitar Rag”
Sources and further reading
Karl Hagstrom Miller, Segregating Sound: Inventing Folk and Pop Music in the Age of Jim Crow, examines how the early record business divided Southern music into racial markets.
The Country Music Hall of Fame and Museum’s From Where I Stand: The Black Experience in Country Music documents Black string bands, songwriters, performers, and musicians whose work became part of country music.
The Handbook of Texas provides histories of segregation in Texas, the Jim Hotel, Alphonso Trent, and the Texas music business.
The Dallas-Fort Worth Professional Musicians Association documents the separate Black and white musicians’ unions in Fort Worth and Dallas.
The Oklahoma Historical Society documents Bob Wills’s early career and the conditions surrounding Western swing in Oklahoma.
Smithsonian Folkways documents Sylvester Weaver’s “Guitar Rag” and its relationship to “Steel Guitar Rag.”